Who's
Afraid of Human Cloning? by Gregory
E. Pence
The beginning of this book is superb and it only
gets better from there. Gregory Pence, a professor of philosophy
and bioethics at the University of Alabama in Birmingham, is unabashedly
in favor of human cloning. Pence talks about attending the first
major conference on human cloning where the pro-cloning position was not
defended in any way. He chastises bioethicists for their condemnation
of cloning and their failure to examine both sides of the issue before
forming opinions. This is the best book on the bioethics of human
cloning as Pence puts all the others to shame.
More information on Who's
Afraid of Human Cloning by Gregory Pence.
Remaking
Eden: Cloning and Beyond in a Brave New World by Lee M. Silver
Lee Silver is a professor at Princeton
University. He is always being quoted in the press about human cloning.
Silver says that human cloning will happen, it's only a matter of time.
This nonfiction book starts out with some astonishing futuristic scenarios
in chapter one. Then things got a little bit boring for me in chapters
two and three where Silver tries to define life and gets into the abortion
debate, but then the book picks up and really excels when it gets back
to cloning and reproduction. One of the interesting things he points
out is the older women at risk for trisomy 21 (downs syndrome) could avoid
that risk with a clone baby. Lee Silver sees a future in which we
clone humans and we genetically engineer them. He shares a lot about
the technology that is going to make it all happen. Silver really
knows the material. He appeared on the McLaughlin Group on 8/28/98
and represented himself very well as the show discussed the future of biotechnology.
On the back cover, David Baltimore, a nobel prize winner, says "Remaking
Eden is the most important book about modern biology that I have seen
recently..." A paperback version with a slightly different title,Remaking
Eden: How Genetic Engineering and Cloning Will Transform the American Family,
has
recently come out. More
on the paperback - Lee
Silver's hardback book
Clone:
The Road to Dolly and the Path Beyond by Gina Kolata
A great book
by Gina Kolata, the New York Times reporter who first broke the cloning
story in the United States. This book goes over the history of cloning
and reviews the science that led to cloning. Kolata has talked to
the key players and we get to know them personally as we read their fascinating
stories. An addional plus is that she exposes some of the questionable
motivations behind the ethics movement in America. I thought the
first chapter was slow, but from there the book took off and did not disappoint.
A back cover blurb by professor Elaine Showalter of Princeton says "Gina
Kolata's Clone is a gripping account of the unlikely adventurers
who produced a stunning scientific breakthrough, and a provocative analysis
of its ethical implications." I found the attempts to whip up ethical controvery
weak, but Kolata's tales of the science behind cloning are magnificent.
Gina
Kolata's Clone
The
Clone Age: Adventures in the New World of Reproductive Technology Age
by Lori B. Andrews
First the good things about this book. It's
well written and an easy read. In fact, at the end of the book Lori
Andrews suggests that it's her memoir. She was one of the first lawyers
to get involved in reproductive law and Andrews is at her best when she
goes over the interesting legal cases she has handled in which she fought
for reproductive rights. It's great when she brings up interesting
legal dilemmas that have come about because of new reproductive technologies.
She's also right on target when she is a patient advocate who says that
men and women need total access to medical information about new reproductive
technologies. What's not so good about the book is that despite the
title it actually has little to do with cloning. It's mostly a book
about infertility and reproductive technology with only a brief mention
of cloning in the prologue and two brief chapters about cloning at the
very end. She's often posing questions about how people would feel
but seldom presents any sort of answer. By the end of the book she
comes across as a person like one who claims all her life not to be prejudiced
but then when her son wants to marry a minority suddenly changes their
view. In other words she is not consistent. She is for reproductive
freedom in the beginning of her career and then shamelessly comes out against
human cloning--an inconsistency that is hard to forgive. It almost
seems that since the entire world came out as anticloning after Dolly she
became a political prostitute and wrote for the presidential commission
(National Bioethics Advisory Commission) exactly what President Clinton
wanted to hear. Some of her ideas about regulation seem like the
Orwellian nightware or Brave New World nightmare that we all want to avoid.
So balancing the positives and negatives, it's a fascinating book, an enjoyable
read, worth buying, but would be a much better book if she had stayed the
course in favor of fighting for reproductive rights.
The
Conquest of Death by Alvin Silverstein
This
is a book that contains many themes related to immortality according to
one of our Web site's fans.
From
Cell to Clone: The Story of Genetic Engineering by Margery and
Howard Facklam
This book was recommended by one of our Web site's
fans. This book is a lot about genetics, but has a chapter on human
cloning.
|